Quote:
Ferretlover: In fact the T8 shadow pants beat the T8.5 shadow pants.
This is not possible. All 25-tier gear is identical in stat-types but with a greater iLvL than its 10-tier equivalent. Tier 8.5 is simply better than the same tier 8 piece in every stat.
I assume you meant the tier 7.5 or the tier 7 is better than 8.5 or 8, because in the end crit is more useful for you once you hit a "soft haste cap". Or you might have instead meant that "even the tier 8 holy pants are better than 8.5 shadow pants" as you had already said 8.5 holy pants are better than 8.5 shadow.
Another thing to consider is while there is a soft haste cap for shadowpriests, you can reach that soft cap with fewer pieces of gear if you get high iLvl gear with haste on it -- it's not a worthless stat, you just need to focus more on crit with your non-set pieces. Half of the tier 8/8.5 Spriest gear has haste on it (technically 3/5, but the hat has both haste and crit so i'm not counting that) so you can account for the haste rating you expect to see on your tier gear ahead of time, 184 total for tier 8, 200 for 8.5
Finally, taking into account the set bonuses, I would be surprised to see a shadow take the 8.5 holy pants, intending on using them for shadow, if they picked up the token.
~Hungraa